Fixed-Term Lease Pitfalls: Why Renewal Is Not Possible and Complete Explanation of Relocation Risks
Fixed-term leases operate on a no-renewal principle. If you sign without understanding this, you may face forced eviction when the contract expires. Experts provide a thorough explanation of how they work, the risks involved, and how to identify them.
When searching for rental properties, you may encounter listings marked as "fixed-term lease." Few people accurately understand how this differs from a standard (indefinite) lease.
A fixed-term lease is a contract form based on Article 38 of the Land and House Lease Act, with the defining feature that . In a standard lease, tenants can generally continue renewing the contract if they wish, but fixed-term leases have no concept of "renewal."
the rental relationship ends automatically when the contract period expires
Established by the 2000 revision to the Land and House Lease Act, fixed-term leases have been used by landlords in situations such as "I want to use the property myself after a certain period" or "I want to rent out my home while on a work transfer." In recent years, they have become more common in investment properties as well.
Key Differences from Standard Leases
The biggest difference between fixed-term and standard leases is how the contract termination is handled.
In a standard lease, landlords must have "legitimate grounds" to refuse renewal, and tenants are protected by law. Even after the contract period expires, landlords cannot demand that tenants vacate without legitimate grounds.
In contrast, a fixed-term lease automatically terminates when the contract period expires. Tenants must move out on the expiration date regardless of whether the landlord has a special reason. This represents significant risk for tenants.
Additionally, fixed-term leases require the following legal procedures:
•Written contract: Oral or telephone agreements are invalid
•Disclosure and explanation in advance: A written explanation stating "there is no renewal and the contract ends upon expiration"
•Notice before expiration: The landlord must notify the tenant in writing between 1 year and 6 months before the expiration date, stating the expiration date and that there is no renewal (except for contracts shorter than 1 year)
If this advance notice is not properly provided, the contract is treated as a standard lease rather than a fixed-term lease.
Characteristics of Properties with Fixed-Term Leases
Properties with fixed-term leases share several common patterns.
Properties rented out temporarily due to work transfers are the most common case. When owners rent out their homes during a multi-year work transfer, they choose fixed-term leases to ensure they can reclaim the property when they return. These properties often have good facilities and location, and rent may be below market rates, but contract periods are typically 2–3 years.
Properties awaiting demolition or major renovation also use fixed-term leases. This applies when a building scheduled for demolition in a few years is rented out for a short period. While rent is low, there is risk that your living environment may change.
Investment properties for rental income are also increasingly using fixed-term leases. In these cases, landlords have greater freedom in setting rent and seek flexibility in renewal conditions.
Risks Tenants Face and How to Address Them
Let's identify the risks that tenants face when signing a fixed-term lease.
The biggest risk is mandatory eviction. When the contract period ends, you must move out if the landlord does not agree to renew. The overall burden is significant—finding new housing, moving expenses, and if applicable, the impact on children from changing schools.
Misalignment with your life plan is also a serious concern. You may be forced to move just before or after your child starts elementary school, or find yourself relocating right when your job has become stable.
To address this, it is important to always confirm the possibility of renewal before signing. Some landlords do agree to renewal if certain conditions are met. However, renewal is entirely at the landlord's discretion and is not legally guaranteed.
It is also important to match the contract period with your life plan. If you plan a short stay of 1–2 years, there is no problem, but if you seek a stable long-term residence, you should prioritize properties with standard leases.
Can You Break the Lease Early?
Generally, early termination of fixed-term leases is not permitted. However, there are exceptions.
Under Article 38, Section 6 of the Land and House Lease Act, for residential properties with a floor area of less than 200 square meters, early termination is permitted with one month's notice only if the tenant has unavoidable circumstances (such as work transfer, medical treatment, or care for a family member).
However, this provision applies only when there are unavoidable circumstances. Reasons such as "I want to move" or "the rent became too high" are not accepted.
If the contract includes a special clause allowing early termination, you can terminate according to those conditions. Before signing, be sure to confirm whether this clause exists and what the conditions are.
How to Identify a Fixed-Term Lease vs. a Standard Lease
When searching for properties, check the following to determine whether it is a fixed-term lease:
Does the "Contract Type" field in the property listing state "fixed-term lease" or "fixed-term building lease"?
Does the disclosure document explain the fixed-term lease?
Does the contract title read "Fixed-Term Building Lease Agreement"?
Ask the real estate agent directly: "Is renewal available?"
Since written advance notice (disclosure document) is legally required before signing a fixed-term lease, confirming that you have received this document is also an important checkpoint.
Summary: Choose Fixed-Term Leases Based on Your Purpose
While fixed-term leases carry significant risk for tenants, they can offer the opportunity to rent well-located, quality properties below market rates. If your purpose is a short-term stay (work assignment, study abroad, or temporary transfer), they may actually be advantageous.
The key is to understand that it is a fixed-term lease before signing. There are countless cases of people unknowingly signing and later facing sudden eviction.
Before signing, always confirm the contract type and make your decision based on how it aligns with your life plan.
If you have concerns, consulting with your local real estate association or legal advice service is also helpful. Since rental contracts are significant long-term commitments, gather sufficient information and make careful decisions.